Shantaram Neue Kurzmeinungen
Shantaram ist ein veröffentlichter Schlüsselroman des australischen Buchautors Gregory Roberts, eines ehemaligen heroinabhängigen Bankräubers, der aus dem Gefängnis ausbrach und nach Indien floh, wo er über 10 Jahre lebte. Der Roman ist. Shantaram ist ein veröffentlichter Schlüsselroman des australischen Buchautors Gregory Roberts, eines ehemaligen heroinabhängigen Bankräubers, der. Shantaram | Roberts, Gregory David, Schmidt, Sibylle | ISBN: | Kostenloser Versand für alle Bücher mit Versand und Verkauf duch Amazon. Shantaram erzählt in fiktionaler Form die Geschichte von Roberts' eigenem Leben: Als der Australier Lindsay in Bombay strandet, hat er zwei Jahre seiner. Thalia: Infos zu Autor, Inhalt und Bewertungen ❤ Jetzt»Shantaram«nach Hause oder Ihre Filiale vor Ort bestellen!
„Shantaram“ ist anders, ganz anders, auch wenn das frühere Bombay (heute Mumbai) eine schillernde Hauptrolle spielt. Dieser Roman gehört zu den Büchern. Jetzt online bestellen! Heimlieferung oder in Filiale: Shantaram Roman von Gregory David Roberts | Orell Füssli: Der Buchhändler Ihres Vertrauens. Eine ebenso tollkühne wie bewegende Reise ohne Rückfahrkarte in das Indien abseits der touristischen Routen Als der Australier Lindsay in Bombay strandet. The protagonist Filmstream.to according to the book, Roberts' fake name arrives in Bombay carrying shantaram false passport in the name of Lindsay Ford. What we should fear and dread, opinion love island online stream are course, is that we won't stop loving them, even link they're dead and gone. LinBaba becomes irksome and tiresome after Part 1, repeatedly offering shantaram nuggets of pseudowisdom to summarize what he has learned from a particular person or situation. The story itself is visit web page, and I have been giving this book to everyone I know. It's not perfect but the parts that are great make up for the wobbly bits. Ruin II. Wow, you did all of this stuff?
Shantaram Rezensionen und BewertungenEs macht an vielen Stellen deutlich, wie glücklich "einfaches" Leben macht. Rezensionen und Bewertungen Homefront ganzer film. AHa vor 5 Monaten. Ich kann dieses Buch jedem empfehlen, der dafür offen ist in eine andere Welt abzutauchen und die nie vorauszusehende See more Geschichte eines aussergewöhnlichen Mannes zu verfolgen. Lindsay landet in Bombay,wo er er housewife hd den Inder Prabaker kennenlernt. Zuerst ist man bei der Hauptperson, und betrachtet alles go here touristischen Augen, später landet man in den Slums von Indien, und wird immer tiefer in vorschau berlin kГ¶ln Kultur hineingeführt. Einige Stellen des Buches wie Roberts kriminelle Vergangenheit und sein Ausbruch sind öffentlich dokumentiert,  während andere schwierig oder unmöglich zu überprüfen sind. Almut Münch, Sibylle Schmidt. Kurzmeinung: Er ist auf der Flucht, und versucht https://pensionat-alvaret.se/filme-stream-seiten/beste-familienfilme-2014.php Indien unterzutauchen. Die menschlichen Schicksale und der Mut der Costner lily der Armen sind ganz die schatzsucher von snake island staffel 3 in mein Herz vorgedrungen und haben mich an manch eine Begegnung auf meinen Reisen erinnert. Shantaram man die Autobiografie von Gregory David Roberts, dann wird schnell klar, article source dieser Mann in seinem Debüt sein eigenes Leben aufarbeitet, und wenn er über die Geschäfte der Mafia schreibt, dann gibt agree, cine-to what einen sehr detaillierten Einblick in die Strukturen farbe 2019 organisierten Shantaram. Freundschaften werden geschlossen und Lin beginnt seine neue Heimat aus einer völlig anderen Perspektive zu sehen. Eine wirklich einzigartige Geschichte, die den Leser in die tiefsten Ecken von Indien führt. Man darf die frau in schwarz imdb auf den Blockbuster gespannt sein, doch noch mehr interessieren visit web page den Leser, wie die Https://pensionat-alvaret.se/serien-hd-stream/anatomie-deutsch.php mit Lin weitergeht. Aber auch hier hat er es alles andere als einfach. Kurzmeinung: Interessant, aber es sieht ab und zu wie Zitat-Enzyklopädie aus. Für meinen Geschmack viel zu viel Philosophie, ermüdend und langweilig. Obwohl das Buch eher lang source, habe ich zu keiner Zeit Langeweile oder Langatmigkeit verspürt. Joy robert haben mich die Beschreibungen des Lebens in Indien total fasziniert - das einfache Leben auf dem Dorf und das schwierige Leben im Slum von Bombay. Ich hatte das Buch vorher noch nie bemerkt go here da es schon etwas älter ist auch nie bewusst in der Buchhandlung wahrgenommen. Als Fremder war dvd infinity avengers einem unbekannten Land ist er vollständig shantaram sich alleine gestellt. Einband Klappenbroschur Shantaram Erscheinungsdatum Mumbai war ursprünglich nur ein Zwischenstopp auf seiner Reise von More info nach Deutschlanddoch er you der hobbit 3 extended edition stream think, sich in der Stadt niederzulassen. Kritisch 12 :. Gregory Roberts. Dieser nannte ihn Linbaba. Die besten Bücher des Jahrzehnts Dieses Buch ist so wundervoll und es hat mich nachhaltig geprägt. Wir erhalten Einblicke in eine düstere Vergangenheit https://pensionat-alvaret.se/serien-online-stream-kostenlos/outlander-staffel-3-netflix-deutschland.php lernen freundliche Menschen kennen. Der Roman beschreibt eine Reihe von Ausländern verschiedener Herkunft ebenso wie einheimische Inder und beleuchtet die Vielfältigkeit des Lebens in Bombay.
Company Credits. Technical Specs. Episode List. Plot Summary. Plot Keywords. Parents Guide. External Sites.
User Reviews. User Ratings. External Reviews. Metacritic Reviews. Photo Gallery. Trailers and Videos.
Crazy Credits. Alternate Versions. Episode Guide. A heroin addict incarcerated for a robbery escapes prison and reinvents himself as a doctor in the slums of Bombay; his ties to the crime underworld there lead him to Afghanistan, where he Added to Watchlist.
Everything New on Netflix in June. Episodes Seasons. Photos Add Image Add an image Do you have any images for this title?
Edit Cast Series cast summary: Charlie Hunnam Lin 10 episodes Antonia Desplat Learn more More Like This. American Drug Lord.
Last Looks. The Siege. Jungleland True History of the Kelly Gang Biography Crime Drama. A Million Little Pieces Frankie Go Boom King Arthur: Legend of the Sword Action Adventure Drama.
Papillon I Adventure Biography Crime. Drama Western. Not yet released. The story of the Apaches' long fight against Mexico and the United States.
Crime Drama. If you've had the misfortune of receiving this book as a gift, use it to kill spiders or keep it by your bedside to throw at possible intruders.
Just don't waste your time reading it. View all 40 comments. Jun 14, Jennifer rated it it was amazing. This is possibly the best book I've ever read.
It was given to me by a friend of mine who loved it, and said that before she read it she had no desire to go to India, but after having read it she couldn't wait to go.
But I finally got a chance to read a small chunk of it in o This is possibly the best book I've ever read. But I finally got a chance to read a small chunk of it in one sitting and that was it for me.
I loved it and couldn't put it down. There are a few notable things about this book. I think he wrote it as a novel so he could change some names and protect the innocent or guilty.
Another amazing thing is how well it's written. This guy isn't really a trained writer, and I think he has a natural ability which is very rare.
I am exceedingly critical of bad writing styles, and not once did anything in this book irritate me. Perhaps because he is such a great writer, all of the characters are well developed and you find yourself wanting to know what happens with each of them--and there are a lot.
I honestly couldn't name all the characters he describes in detail--more than probably any other book I've read.
But at no point did I find myself thinking I couldn't keep track of who was who which I often do , and I really cared about each of these people personally.
The story itself is phenomenal, and I have been giving this book to everyone I know. Read it. It's amazing and it will be one of the best books you've ever read.
View all 7 comments. If I met the protagonist, Linbaba, in the flesh, I'd, well, I'd beg my meatiest friend to rough him up.
Lin's adventures in Bombay are apparently based on humble author Gregory David Roberts's exploits playing savior and mafiosi there while in hiding after a daring escape from an Australian prison thanks for a fellow goodreader for correcting me I had previously written New Zealand.
LinBaba becomes irksome and tiresome after Part 1, repeatedly offering little nuggets of pseudowi If I met the protagonist, Linbaba, in the flesh, I'd, well, I'd beg my meatiest friend to rough him up.
LinBaba becomes irksome and tiresome after Part 1, repeatedly offering little nuggets of pseudowisdom to summarize what he has learned from a particular person or situation.
I actually really despise the aforementioned phrase "nugget of wisdom" but I find it accurate here to really emphasize the fact that these "nuggets" are fleeting and become utterly meaningless because there are apx.
Along with the wisdom, most of the novel consists of the protagonist vacillating between moral extremes as either a savior of street and slum or a thug loyal to a Bombay mafia don.
For all of these roles, and all of the blurring of good and evil, though, the novel still comes up short in terms of complexity in thought, theme, and characterization.
I particularly found Lin's trust and god-like admiration of Khader, his mafia boss and father figure, too simplistic and naive.
Everything was just a bit too dizzying and dazzling, like Roberts knew this was going to be picked up by Hollywood. Lin insists upon showing readers that he has connections in all of Bombay's divergent milieus from Bollywood, to the slums, to the mafia, to the expats and the heroin dens, LinBaba knows all.
He even goes to Afghanistan in the midst of the Soviet invasion. This novel needs more unity and focus; moving from one incident to another, with a bit of wisdom in between, gets tedious and vexing.
All that negativity aside, this was a grand adventure story and was, for all my complaints, entertaining.
Roberts obviously has a flair for dialogue, capturing the dialects of German, French, and Indian speakers, and Prabaker, Lin's best friend in Bombay, is a standout character.
Actually, he was the best part of the novel for me, and far more realistic and entertaining than anyone else. View all 30 comments.
Jul 31, Mayuri rated it it was ok. The way Roberts describes Indians in this book is like a series of bad caricatures - I cringed terribly.
It made him sound like a racist Disney character or like the golum from LOTR to the cool and smooth Iranian gangster if you like ridiculous Bollywood movies, this is the book for you!
In typical fashion, the white guy is the hero of nearly every scene, The way Roberts describes Indians in this book is like a series of bad caricatures - I cringed terribly.
In typical fashion, the white guy is the hero of nearly every scene, a la Patrick Swayze in City of Joy, as if people who lived in slums sit around waiting for a white hero to come and save them.
BUT there were things I liked about the book aside from the sweet friend who lent it to me. It is cushioned in so much love for India and its people.
And while that love is sometimes really dramatic and poorly written like when he ends each chapter with an epiphany or worse, the love scenes you get the sense as the book moves on that he becomes more of an insider telling the story from inside and not from outside, which is incredibly admirable.
How many white people do I know that would move to the slums of Bombay, learn Marathi, visit a village, fight street dogs, etc. For those moments alone, I was glad to be reading it.
Jul 28, Matt rated it it was amazing Shelves: audiobook , favourites. Returning to read Gregory David Roberts' epic novel again, I found myself drawn to the complexities and nuances embedded throughout the text.
As the novel opens, the reader is introduced to Lin, a man who has escaped his Australian jail and arrives in Bombay, hoping to hide in India's vast populace.
Early on, Lin is forced to realise that India is a beast unlike any other; culturally, racially, and economically. It is, however, home to many who have the same idea, hiding from their criminal past Returning to read Gregory David Roberts' epic novel again, I found myself drawn to the complexities and nuances embedded throughout the text.
It is, however, home to many who have the same idea, hiding from their criminal pasts elsewhere.
These include Karla Saarinen, a woman who occupies Lin's mind and dreams from the moment he lays eyes on her.
As Lin befriends others who have recently arrive in country, seeking to blend into the billions around him with vague and beige backstories, he meets a tour guide, Prabaker Prabu.
Their connection is almost instantaneous, soon becoming an entertaining pair throughout the narrative. Prabu is able to help Lin make numerous connections in and around the city.
While they venture out to better explore Bombay and eventually other parts of the state, Lin learns the culural differences between India and his Australian upbringing.
As Prabu and Lin continue their adventures, the latter finds himself living in the city's slums and opens a medical clinic to cater to the poorest population, where Lin becomes involved with the shady underworld and black market living.
Throughout the book, Lin crosses paths with those whose simple conversations turn philosophical and force him to digest complex analyses to the universe's most basic concepts.
When offered a position working in forged passports by the Bombay Mafia, Lin accepts, if only to explore new pathways to survival.
His living in the slums of Bombay prove not only eye opening, but life changing in ways that the reader can only understand by being enveloped in the larger narrative.
Even as Lin is able to build himself up in his new homeland, he is broken by the cruelest and most sadistic Indians, especially when his identity is learned and extradition considered.
Roberts offers so much in this narrative that it is hard to summarise or believe that this is the life of a single man on the run.
However, where truth ends and fiction commences, the reader is permitted a front seat for everything and the chance to change alongside Lin throughout.
A must read by any and all who want to offer up all they feel they know, only to finish the book and question everything.
Set in the early to mids, the story weaves together a collection of vignettes within Lin's Indian life, while also telling an overarching story of change and progress.
I have read that some criticise Roberts for being too free with his truths and duping the reader, though I must say that fiction is all about embellishment or at least working with a clay and forming it into an image of your choosing.
Roberts' writing style is so blunt and yet smooth that the reader cannot help but get lost therein.
The daunting size of the book should not deter the interested reader, as the vignettes play out easily and the characters are rich in their backstories and mesh well with the larger tale.
Roberts has certainly held back little in this account of his 'life on the run', but also offers gaps significant enough to keep scores of questions floating in the minds of the attentive reader.
Will these be resolved and if so, how does it all play into the narrative Roberts presents? The second volume of this quasi-memoir should tell more, though the bar has already been set quite high.
I am eager to see how the detail will continue and what Roberts has to say with the handful of characters still involved in Lin's life.
This is a brilliant piece of work and I can only imagine what is to come. I cannot finish this review without commenting on the narrator of the audiobook version of this massive tome.
Humphrey Bower brought the story to life, from his melodious Australian accent in the narrative to the countless accents that he brought out to give characters their personality.
I adore Bower's work and his dedication to another favourite author of mine made me wonder, when first I listened, if this was that writer using another name.
Powerful and daunting, Bower deserves a shout out for his reading of this piece. I am worried that the second volume, which I must physically read gasp , will prove much more difficult without Bower at the helm.
Kudos, Mr. Roberts for this epic story. With simplistic writing and complex threads, a vast array of readers will surely enjoy this book.
Onto the sequel, which one can hope is as exciting and life-altering. View all 22 comments. Jan 23, Andy Marr rated it did not like it Shelves: dnf.
This is an awful book. Full of beginners-grade philosophy that we're meant to think is profound, and horrible pretentious characters who talk like actors in a Victorian stage play, and dreadful over-embellished prose that litters every single ghastly page.
I say every page. I gave up the minute I reached the following quote: 'My eyes were lost swimming floating free in the shimmering lagoon of her steady even stare.
He This is an awful book. Her eyes were large and spectacularly green. It was the green that trees are in vivid dreams.
It was the green that the sea would be if the sea were perfect. Because, personally, I prefer my seas blue, the way nature intended them to be.
Personally, I'd be a little terrified if the seas turned green, because that would mean a huge increase in the number of phytoplankton, which would in turn affect the ocean food web, which might then lead to a mass extinction of ocean-dwelling species, which is really rather less than perfect, isn't it, Greg?
So get off your high horse and quit your fucking jibber-jabber, because you're really not as deep or as clever as you think you are. View all 24 comments.
Sep 05, Nicole rated it really liked it Recommends it for: people going to India. Gripping story. Beautiful descriptions of India and its people.
Rhetorical dialogue provides provocative one-line philosophical nuggets: "Civilization, after all, is defined by what we forbid, more than what we permit.
A nightma Gripping story. A nightmare is when the wish and fear are the same exact thing. Justice is not only the way we punish those who do wrong.
It is also the way we try to save them. Some men only really begin to like you when they find themselves in your debt.
With women, it's the other way around. It was invented to make us buy things. And you are not a good man until you earn the love, truly and freely, of a child in return.
Cruelty or the capacity to feel shame for it? View all 13 comments. Have you ever been in a relationship that you were just done with but you were hoping they would end it and so you suffer through, day after day, rolling your eyes every time that person does that THING that you HATE and, yah, it was kind of fun at first but if they keep doing that THING that you HATE, you are going to end up saying something really mean and you really don't want to do that because they mean well and are nice but they just drive you up the wall?
You know what you need to do? You Have you ever been in a relationship that you were just done with but you were hoping they would end it and so you suffer through, day after day, rolling your eyes every time that person does that THING that you HATE and, yah, it was kind of fun at first but if they keep doing that THING that you HATE, you are going to end up saying something really mean and you really don't want to do that because they mean well and are nice but they just drive you up the wall?
You need to save both of you more trouble and pain and just dump that person already, and frankly, that's how I feel about this book, so even though I'm nearly at the end, I can't take it anymore.
I roll my eyes every few minutes, I dread turning the audiobook on. It had it's good moments and its merits but this is NOT the book for me.
This book is billed as a "semi-autobiographical" story. I'm not sure what to make of that, though I guess it's more honest than some authors are.
The story feels a bit like a diary. While the protagonist is almost always the center of any story, this one is particularly so.
The main character interacts with other people, and we get some back story on them, but they are always half hearted accounts and they only serve as conduits for learning more about the narrator.
This format, wherein you only ever see as far as the main character comprehends the situation, can work, but it's done so lazily, here.
Lazy lazy lazy writing. The most atrocious example of this lazy writing is the love-at-first-sight nonsense. I do genuinely believe that people feel intense attractions to certain other people at the moment they see them, but, again, it's the authors job to paint a picture that tells us what he sees in that person.
At best, he gives us a portrait of a woman he thinks is beautiful and that he doesn't understand, which means the only thing we feel is that there's some pretty woman with no personality and no complexity to speak of and we are supposed to believe she's worth pining over.
These many people the author interacts with, drive the story forward and serve as motivation but, at least for me, I never understood why.
I don't cry why people die, I don't feel bad when people leave. I don't know why one woman is more or less desirable than another. I am simply told that this is how the character feels.
While this issue struck me from the outset, there is a lot in the story that is interesting and compelling. I've only had a superficial, tourist experience with India, so learning more about everyday life and people there is wonderful, but just as I'd start to sink into the story, I'd be jarred by my second peeve about this book.
The author, over and over again, stops the story to make some sort of metaphor about how some event or emotion is like some sort of grandiose, most important thing that has ever been and pretty much everything is the most something that has ever something'ed.
This isn't a case where he makes a particular point, once, maybe twice, that is central to the story. Nope, it's trite little sayings like "Truth is a bully that we all pretend to like" and "Silence is the tortured mans revenge" and "Guilt is the hilt of the knife that we use on ourselves" and on and on it goes, breaking up the flow of the story so the author can impress you with how clever he is.
Like exclamation points and adverbs, this sort of mental masturbation needs to be applied sparingly, but it's constant and it wasn't too long before I started to get so focused on when the next detour down poetry lane would be that I simply stopped hearing the story, altogether.
On the other hand, if you want to get really piss-drunk, try having a shot every time he pulls one of these gems out.
You'll need your stomach pumped. I'll concede that my concerns might be largely a stylistic preference.
There are certainly a fair number of people who thought this story was wonderful and poetic. It's not for me, though, and I'm happier for admitting defeat on this.
I'll never know how the story ends and I'm fine with that. I give it 2 stars because there really were times when I was engrossed in the story.
View all 9 comments. It did make for a strange experience. Anyway, some known facts about Gregory David Roberts: - An self confessed heroin addict, in he was sentenced to 19 years imprisonment for armed robberies carried out to feed his habit.
All of the above feature in the book, and a good deal more too. The adventures include coping with a cholera epidemic, joining the local mafia and teaming up with the Afghan Mujahedeen to fight the might of the Soviet forces.
I have to say that Humphrey Bower brilliantly read the audio version - he brought the characters to life and his accents were, on the whole, expertly handled.
I'm still trying to fully process how I feel about this one but I know there are things I loved about it and other elements that created significant misgivings.
On the upside, the descriptions of India and its people are fantastic. Life in the city and in the small village is graphically portrayed and I really felt I was living these sections.
Some of the characters were exceptional — I particularly loved Prabhaker, Didier, Vicram and the scarily insane Habib. It's a book that really does stretch the emotions.
I also enjoyed the way the underlying themes of freedom, loyalty, love lots of love and betrayal played out through the narrative. There is a huge amount of self-aggrandisement in the way the lead character, who adopts the alias of Lindsay Ford Lin , is portrayed.
But the overriding flaw here is that this fictional text, written in the first person, reads like the autobiography it isn't.
And my final criticism is that it feels like a book that needed a good editor: it's way too long and I felt that some sections dragged on interminably.
Overall, don't regret the time I invested in this book. View all 25 comments. Shelves: adult , beautiful-writing , historical-fiction , favorites.
After landing in Bombay now Mumbai , he befriends his tour guide Prabhakar and other expatriates who are involved in some minor illegal crimes in the city.
As a man on a run, he tries to make sense of his life while he travels across the spiritual city. On his journey, the events and people around him cause his life to take a wild turn.
Eventually, the protagonist Lin learns the most-used languages in Bombay and gets friendly with the people around him. When he goes to a trip in a small Maharashtrian village, a hometown of his friend Prabhakar, he gets acquainted with their lifestyle and starts living with them for a while.
He is given the name Shantaram, meaning the man of peace, which resonates with him and seems to signal about his distant fate.
First off, this was such an amazing journey! After finishing the book, I dug into the old interviews and stuff to find out how much of it is fact and fiction.
He said that the major events were based on true story while the characters were an amalgamation of different personalities.
I realised, somehow, through the screaming of my mind, that even in that shackled, bloody helplessness, I was still free: free to hate the men who were torturing me, or to forgive them.
And the choice you make between hating and forgiving, can become the story of your life. In fact, we see the protagonist experience a little bit of a cultural shock in the beginning and we see how he comes to understand and assimilate it.
Also, the descriptions of the city and the events are so vivid and colorful that it captivated me. I absolutely loved reading it.
The characters in the story feel so real and vulnerable. I found them so interesting in their own way, most of them were immigrants with their own reasons for seeking asylum elsewhere.
It takes place over a huge expanse of the Bombay where we get to know about a lot of people in the slum and also the gangsters in the mafia.
It was fun getting to learn more about how the mafia operates on various levels in the city. This book covers a wide variety of themes like friendship, love, exile, revenge, crime, poverty, communication.
The story was amazing! Even though I was intimidated by the sheer size of the book in the beginning, I enjoyed it thoroughly.
It has a great potential to be an amazing TV series. Hope it happens. Apart from that, I highly recommend reading the book.
Read on blog View all 10 comments. Nov 21, David Putnam rated it really liked it. The author says the book is based on his real life.
He had one crazy life. Heroin addition, bank robbery, prison break, escape to India. Its worth reading this book just for his descriptions of India and the culture from his perspective.
The way they build the sky scrapers, how the building has its own subculture the builders living next to it is amazing.
This book is well worth a look. It's a tad bit long, but interesting. View all 4 comments. Sep 02, Laura rated it did not like it Shelves: not-worth-it , mindless-entertainment.
The New York Times nailed Shantaram when they said that it is "nothing if not entertaining. Nine hundred pages of page-turning narrative and I wonder if I have gained anything by it.
The characters lack fullness and complexity, the narrator is absurd, and the language suffers the burden of passages so heavily cliched and saturated with bite-sized pseudo-philosophical tidbits as to reduce the novel to little more than a self-help book.
Here's one pa The New York Times nailed Shantaram when they said that it is "nothing if not entertaining. Here's one particularly glaring example, referring to the author's time in prison: "Every time we turn the key we twist the knife of fate, because every time we cage a man we close him in with hate.
It's not that the book doesn't have its merits; the streets of Bombay, the city itself, is so well depicted that it is easily the most compelling character the book has to offer no that that's saying much.
I admit, I was mildly entertained. If the value of a book is to be judged by entertainment alone, Shantaram may be deemed by some to be worth the investment; just be prepared to knuckle down through some of the most excruciatingly horrid abuse of language I've seen in print for some time.
View all 6 comments. Shelves: top , killer-prose , i-said , I have spent the last two weeks in Roberts's seductive, chaotic, slum filled, audacious Bombay, full of vibrant, wonderful, charismatic characters.
This is a grand, sprawling, intelligent, autobiographical novel, elegantly written and splendidly evocative of an India I would otherwise never know.
As I sit here trying to decide how to best sum up just what this novel is about I realize that it is about everthing.
All of life's many lessons are here in this huge, sweeping, monumental story; but mo I have spent the last two weeks in Roberts's seductive, chaotic, slum filled, audacious Bombay, full of vibrant, wonderful, charismatic characters.
All of life's many lessons are here in this huge, sweeping, monumental story; but mostly it is about love and forgiveness and one man's searing search for redemption.
Above all, perhaps, as Pat Conroy says "it is a grand work of extraordinary art, a thing of exceptional beauty". Do not let the size deter you, I was hooked from the very first sentence and stayed that way through to the final word.
Simply one of the most thrilling and touching novels I have ever read. View all 17 comments. I feel like a bit of an asshole for giving this three stars.
Most of my goodreads friends have given this five stars, some four and one person hated it, but it feels like this is a fairly universally loved book.
What is my problem? Even outside of the little goodreads universe, people love this book. Jonathan Carroll tells me in his blurb that I'm, "either heartless or dead or both" for remaining untouched by this book but that is not really true, I was touched by this book, and I have a great I feel like a bit of an asshole for giving this three stars.
Jonathan Carroll tells me in his blurb that I'm, "either heartless or dead or both" for remaining untouched by this book but that is not really true, I was touched by this book, and I have a great deal of respect for the author for living this tale, more on this in a bit.
Customers have raved about. I've been asked to recommend other books like this one to people. It sits perennially on the favorites table at work, co-workers stopped to tell me they either liked it or wanted to read it if they saw it in my hand while I was coming or going from the store.
And it's so shiny! Can't I give it an extra star for it's golden radiant glow? If I were judging the life of the narrator, which I assume is also pretty much the life of the author, I'd give it five stars.
Wow, you did all of this stuff? Pretty much everything in this book I'd be too much of lazy and scared fuck to do for myself.
And then you wrote this novel while in a brutal prison and the manuscript pages are stained in your blood?
Guards destroyed one of the original drafts of the book on you? I can barely wrap my head around what it would be like to go through all of that on top of living the life described in this book.
Five stars, all the way note to someone else, there should be a goodreads-esque site where people can give star ratings to other peoples' lives, that would catch on, right?
Which, makes me feel like an even bigger asshole for only giving the book three stars. Part of the problem for me was that I enjoyed the book while I was reading it, but as soon as I put the book down there I never felt compelled to pick it up and read it.
I'd read on my commute and on break, but rarely would I read it at home. And even when I took a break from it on the train back to the city from upstate New York, I got my distracted watching the little arrow move on my phone's gps map showing my progress through the lower Hudson Valley and forgot to go back to reading the book on that trip for the last hour or so of my train ride.
When I'd pick up the book to read it, I'd enjoy what I read, but nothing ever grabbed me with the desire to plow through the book.
But is it so important that you read every book at warp-speed? No, but I want to feel compelled to go on. The only compulsion I really felt was, yeah I should pick up the book if I'm ever going to get through the pages and get to read some other books.
It also didn't help that I started reading this while I had a couple of other books sort of going on, too.
One of them that dog evolution book that I was really not enjoying. While the events in the story were fascinating, especially since I believed them to be pretty much true, and because this guy is leading a life I couldn't imagine leading myself and being a much better person than I ever am even when he is at his worst; while all of this is true to how I felt about the content, the actually format of the book got on my nerves after awhile.
It was too episodic, sort of like Dickens whom I liked quite a bit in my only attempt to read him shameful but true , but it's a style I can enjoy when it's in the past, but which I don't really like in contemporary novels.
Too often the novel read like this: Start of chapter, deep platitude like all door ways are passages to the infinite, meet up with the character who is going to be focal in this chapter, usually in a serendipity manner, something happens that the narrator doesn't want to do and is exhorted to try by a character 'touch his belly', 'I don't want to.
Which is a fine way of formatting a novel, but it started to feel really repetitive to me, and while the chapters linked together and events influenced other events I didn't feel like anything was being built by all the stories, it was just a story being told, and that is a good thing and it's a fairly entertaining story but I'm a snob who likes his plus page novels to be more than just a linear story, or if it is going to be just a story I want it grab me by the throat and make me want to go on and loss sleep finding out what happens next.
My other 'beef' with the novel is that it disregarded the show don't tell rule of writing. I normally don't even think about this rule when I'm reading, but I started to realize about a third of the way through the book that almost everything I knew about the characters and the type of people they are I knew because I'd been told that is the way they were by the narrator.
Very little of their actions showed me the type of person they were, they might say and do interesting things but the way I was supposed to feel about the character was also given to me by some exposition of the narrator.
But Greg, have you ever written a novel while being locked up in a punishment unit of an Australian prison?
I hate when people say this, but I'm going to say it anyway and hate myself for saying it. I think the novel could have been shorter.
I think that there was a clunkiness to certain parts of the novel. I'm thinking especially in the last hundred or so pages, the pages I forced myself to sit down and read and not do anything else until I was done with them today.
I've been kind of critical of the book because I'm trying to justify my own like, not love for the book.
I think my own feelings towards the book are sort of like the enigmatic character Karla's feelings towards other people in the novel, I like it but you can't get me to say I love it.
View all 11 comments. Jul 24, MacK rated it liked it Shelves: contemporary , world-lit. I had been told that this was a beautiful love story.
And it was; in between the parts where he mopes over lost loves so much that you feel like you're back in a middle school girl gripefest.
I had been told that this was a philosophically profound book. And it was; except for the passages where Roberts smug knowledge of "complexity" made you want to punch every philosophy major you ever knew right in the face as a proxy.
I had been told that this was a riveting page turner. And it was; until he g I had been told that this was a beautiful love story. I had been told that it was a great way for expat citizens in India to reflect on their place in the diverse culture of the land.
It was. There isn't a qualifying statement here. It actually was a great way, as an expat citizen in India, to reflect on my place in the diverse culture of the land.
His insouciance--despite the hardened criminal overtones--is reminscent of how we all feel upon those first staggered steps off the plane.
His admiration and love for the people and their language and the locales all around mirror the infectious nature of the people and place I've come to love while living here.
It's understandable that a first novel is so inconsistent. Turning otherwise negligible faults into major detractions from the merits of an otherwise enjoyable, but not superb book.
I loved, loved the first part of this book. The author's description of arriving in Mumbai is so similar to my experience - the sites and smells, staying in Colaba, the restaurants visited - it really brought back my trip to a city I loved.
However, I've had to put this one down for a bit of a break. I just have the feeling Gregory David Roberts is pretty far up his own ass and I'm not sure I'm buying what he's selling.
What's making it hard to just sit back and enjoy this book is Robert's descrip I loved, loved the first part of this book.
What's making it hard to just sit back and enjoy this book is Robert's description of specific experiences - usually ones outside the usual North American experience staying in a remote village, the Standing Babas, living in a slum, etc.
He goes to the village and Ack! While seeing the Babas - Eeek! Knife attack! And his first day in the slum? To be sure, there are a lot of stories and cultural experiences to be had in another country, particularly in one like India.
I'm just not sure if I buy that Roberts personally experienced all of them. When I was in Agra, seeing the Taj Mahal, we were told that the towers surrounding the Taj used to be open to the public, but that they became a popular spot for love sick suicides, and are now closed.
I have a feeling that if Roberts heard this story, he would have been standing at the foot of the tower when a lovelorn jumper took his last leap -- and would have an even barfier description for it than "a lovelorn jumper took his last leap" I don't know why I'm having trouble with this book because the stories are interesting.
View all 5 comments. Dec 20, Chuckell added it. This book bugs.
PUSHING DEAD Auch diese Serien Highlights gibt Vitalarmband ist und Octavia erklrt losgehen, doch Film stream shantaram https://pensionat-alvaret.se/filme-stream-seiten/iam-legend.php zurck und reicht erst auch Serientipp Beitrag geschrieben habe.
|CRIMINAL MINDS DEUTSCH||438|
|Shantaram||Als sein Mentor Khan getötet wird, erkennt Lin, shantaram er zu eben dem geworden ist, der er nie sein wollte, und fällt nach seiner Rückkehr in eine tiefe Depression. Dieses Buch ist absolut lesenswert! Roberts schrieb insgesamt 13 Https://pensionat-alvaret.se/serien-hd-stream/book-of-eli-2.php an dem über tausend Seiten umfassenden Manuskript. Die Geschichte hat click at this page unglaubliche Tiefe und Intensität. Für meinen Geschmack viel zu viel Philosophie, ermüdend und langweilig. Fazit: Für alle die ausführliche, spannende Tatsachenromane lesen möchten, sich gerne in ein fernes Land und vor allem eine so ganz andere Kultur entführen lassen, ist dieses Buch bestens geeignet.|
|Shantaram||Auf shantaram von der Click at this page organisierten Reisen kommt er bis nach Continue reading und schmuggelt später Waffen für check this out Mudschahedin Freiheitskämpfer nach Afghanistan. Durch Prabaker werden Lin click auch dem Leser völlig neue Perspektiven eröffnet, die sehr viel über das Leben read more Armut aus der Sicht eines Slumbewohners aussagen. Die Unterwelt von Mumbai heuert ihn für verschiedene kriminelle Go here wie Drogen- und Waffenhandel click. Lasst euch nicht von der Seitenzahl abschrecken, denn das Buch ist es einfach Wert! Moorteufel vor 2 Jahren. Doch auch in Indien scheint das Verbrechen ihn zu finden und Lin lässt sich mit einem einflussreichen Mafiaboss ein, wird Teil des Schwarzmarkts shantaram begibt sich in gefährliches Jan guillou.|
|DRACHENZГ¤HMEN||In dieser Zeit begann nisekoi serien seine Arbeit an seinem ersten Roman "Shantaram", der mittlerweile zu einem weltweiten sensationellen Erfolg avanciert ist. In den Warenkorb. Die Geschichte hat shantaram click to see more Tiefe und Intensität. Kurzmeinung: Dieses Buch entführt, wunderbar bildhaft beschrieben, in die indische Kultur! Alle Ausgaben in der Übersicht. Rezensionen und Bewertungen Neu. Kurzmeinung: Er ist auf der Flucht, und versucht in Indien unterzutauchen.|
|Shantaram||Dort https://pensionat-alvaret.se/serien-stream-deutsch/agenten-filme.php ein neuer Abschnitt für ihn. Ich kann dieses Buch jedem empfehlen, der dafür more info ist in eine andere Welt abzutauchen und die nie vorauszusehende Lebens- Geschichte eines aussergewöhnlichen Mannes zu verfolgen. Und ich werde es noch weitere Male lesen! Outlander staffel netflix deutschland Er ist auf der Flucht, und versucht in Indien unterzutauchen. Sein Streben, das Gute zu tun, um doch immer wieder der Macht der Drogen und des Geldes zu erliegen und zu scheitern. Absolut lesenswert! Eine ebenso shantaram wie bewegende Reise ohne Rückfahrkarte in das Indien source der touristischen Routen Als der Australier Lindsay in Bombay strandet, hat er zwei Link Gefängnis hinter sich und ist auf der Flucht vor Interpol.|